New Homes allocation not subject to infrastructure delivery and maintenance!

Of the major infrastructure components, relied upon and promised in the Castle Point Local Plan draft New and 1998 versions, Flood Defence maintenance is probably the most significant.

With the current round of National Budgetary cut backs due to be announced, concerns are raised about the spending required for the sea defences protecting the residents of Canvey Island.

Whilst our decision makers and officers claim that Flooding either from the estuary or from surface water should not be a constraint on housing and business development, others suggest caution.

These issues are not raised by us, the Canvey Green Belt Campaign group, but by the Association of British Insurers.

We may do well to take notice, as few at Castle Point Borough Council appear to!


Spending Review 2015: Maintenance for flood defences needs to be protected from short-sighted cuts

Mark Shepherd

18 November 2015

Mark Shepherd, Manager, General Insurance, ABI

We can expect to hear lots of talk about difficult decisions ahead of the Spending Review on November 25, when the Chancellor will announce his plans for the use of public money over the course of this Parliament.

George Osborne has indicated capital expenditure at Defra is safe from cuts. In a statement provided to the ABI earlier this month, Floods Minister Rory Stewart commented, “Flooding can devastate lives, homes and businesses. That’s why we are investing in flood protection at record levels, with an unprecedented six-year commitment of £2.3 billion to better protect an additional 300,000 homes by 2021.” The ABI welcomes this confirmation of funding, that we fought hard to secure and which will protect homes and businesses, and save money in the long run.

However, with DEFRA’s resource budget set to be cut by 30% over the next four years, sadly there remains doubt about an equally vital area of spending – that of flood defence maintenance.

More than £100m was spent a year on flood defences in 2010/11, but since, this spending has reduced by 40%. 

Building a brand new house should provide shelter for decades to come, but that only holds true if you also invest the necessary time and money in keeping the walls and roof in a good state of repair. The same applies to this nation’s flood defences. Spending millions on new defences is only part of the job. Neglect the vital maintenance to keep our flood defences in the right condition and that valuable investment is left in danger of crumbling at just the time it is needed the most.

More than £100m was spent a year on flood defences in 2010/11, but since, this spending has reduced by 40%. Flood defence maintenance needs to be considered alongside investment in building defences to prevent the deterioration of new and existing defences. At a time when the impact of climate change is growing and nation’s flood risk is increasing, it is short-sighted to cut back on the funding which keeps the defences we have, and are set to build, in good working order.

In the wake of the 2013/14 winter floods, there was not only a financial price to pay. Memories of the damage done to communities up and down the UK should still be fresh in the minds of those in Whitehall who are looking at what savings the country can afford to make. As the families who had to spend months out of their wrecked homes, and the thousands of home owners who rely on flood defences to keep them safe, would tell them – cuts to flood defence maintenance are not affordable.

Mark Shepherd is Manager, General Insurance at the Association of British Insurers. floodfreehomes


One response to “New Homes allocation not subject to infrastructure delivery and maintenance!

  1. The Drainage system and its infrastructure on Canvey Island are considered to be by Planning Officers as being Asset, for which they have no responsibility for when deliberating upon planning applications.

    This aspect will give concerns to the Insurance Industry and Mortgage Providers who could not discount the following comment from the recent flood investigation reports.

    “Canvey has been developed on an extremely flat and low lying estuarine island in the mouth of the River Thames with a land height of approximately 1m below the mean high water level, its current form being the result of nearly 500 years of land reclamation and drainage. The island has been historically susceptible to all sources of flooding, and is protected from tidal flooding by a sea wall on all sides. As a consequence the water level on the other side of the sea wall is regularly higher than the land, meaning that the drainage of surface water is wholly reliant on pumps to discharge water into the estuary at these times. These pumps are the final element of a long, incredibly complex and interlinked surface water drainage system, comprising of drains, culverts, sewers, open watercourses, main rivers, pumps and storage areas all with varying capacity, which need to be operating efficiently in order to drain the island. Rainfall on the island may flow a substantial distance before reaching the pumps, through infrastructure owned or managed by a large number of different organisations and individuals and in some cases without a clear understanding of ownership. Any constriction on flow either due to blockage or insufficient capacity for the rainfall event can affect the effective operation of the entire drainage system.”

    The Planning Officers and Councillors when considering the allowance of further developments on the Zone 3a flood plain would do well to revisit the Thames Estuary 2100 report specifically that part that deals with Canvey Island. Clearly this report highlights that CPBC are very small players when fighting for flood mitigation funding despite the fact that Canvey Islands sea defence requirements of maintenance and improvements are considered to be JUSTIFIED.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s